Preparing a TR Index Peer-Review Process File Is Now Easier: ODİS

ODİS Peer-Review Process File Builder logo

FROM SCATTERED DOCUMENTS TO ONE FILE

Document the peer-review process faster, more clearly and more completely.

TR Index logo

ODİS is an independent, free supporting tool. It is not an official application developed by TR Index or TÜBİTAK.

Publishing an academic article involves more than scientific evaluation. From the original submission and reviewer reports to revision files and evaluation dates, the entire process must be recorded in an orderly way and be ready for presentation when required.

This becomes especially important for journals applying to, or evaluated by, TR Index. The evaluation process for selected articles must be submitted as a coherent and traceable record.

What does TR Index expect in a peer-review process file?

Under the current criteria, the full peer-review history of an article should be presented as a single PDF file. The file is expected to include:

  • The manuscript as originally submitted,
  • the first reviewer’s report,
  • the second reviewer’s report,
  • where applicable, a third reviewer’s report and further review rounds,
  • revisions sent to the author, the revised manuscript or author responses,
  • reviewer names and affiliations,
  • evaluation dates, and
  • signed reviewer reports where possible.

Keeping reviewer reports is therefore only part of the job. Documenting the entire process in the correct order and without omissions is an important part of editorial management.

From DergiPark to OJS: the invisible editorial workload

Integrated journal platforms such as DergiPark make it easier to follow submissions, reviewer assignments, evaluations and revisions in one place. Journals using OJS or similar infrastructures—or conducting parts of the review process by email—often need to prepare the TR Index process file separately and mostly by hand.

Editors may face a scattered collection of files: the first manuscript is a Word document, one reviewer report is a scanned PDF, another is stored in a different format, and the author’s revision file sits in another folder. A second review round or a third reviewer’s report can easily be overlooked.

Some reports may also lack a visible reviewer name, affiliation or evaluation date. Finding the documents, converting them, putting them in order, creating a cover and table of contents, adding page numbers and checking for missing items can take considerable time.

The problem is not only lost time

Incorrectly ordered or incomplete documents can make a sound review process difficult to examine. A well-managed evaluation becoming less visible because of missing records is an avoidable risk for editors and editorial boards.

Why does a missing document matter?

TR Index requires the requested journal issues and reviewer reports to be uploaded on time and in full during application and evaluation. Its official guidance notes that missing materials may prevent a journal from being evaluated and may lead to rejection for the relevant year.

A peer-review process file is therefore not just a technical upload. It is evidence of the journal’s scientific evaluation system, reviewer contribution and editorial traceability.

How does ODİS address this need?

ODİS—the TR Index Peer-Review Process File Builder—was developed for this purpose. It is a free supporting tool that combines the original manuscript, reviewer reports, revision documents and related files into a single, organised and page-numbered PDF.

The application supports PDF, Word (.docx) and image files. Different formats can be used in the same project without converting every file in a separate program.

No technical knowledge required

  1. Enter the journal and article details for the cover.
  2. Add reviewer names, affiliations and evaluation dates.
  3. Drag the original manuscript, reviewer reports and revision files into the relevant areas.
  4. Select the document type and review round.
  5. Review the missing-document check.
  6. Create the single PDF.

ODİS arranges the uploaded documents in the selected order and automatically creates a cover page, table of contents and page numbers. Reports from a third reviewer and multiple evaluation rounds can also be classified by reviewer and round.

Spot missing documents before creating the file

ODİS does more than merge files: it makes gaps visible during preparation. If the original manuscript, a required reviewer report or essential information is missing, the user can see the warning before generating the PDF.

This helps editors identify omissions without reading hundreds of combined pages from beginning to end. Final review and compliance with the latest TR Index criteria remain the responsibility of the journal’s editorial team; ODİS simply brings the points that need attention together on one screen.

Saving time and creating a consistent standard

Preparing process files manually requires searching, conversion, merging, ordering and repeated checking. The workload grows quickly when the same process is repeated for several articles.

With ODİS, editors can drag in the documents and complete the necessary fields. The result is a consistent file structure in which reviewer and date information is visible, multiple reviewers and rounds remain traceable, and missing documents are easier to notice.

Your documents are processed on your device

Reviewer reports and unpublished manuscripts are confidential. Files added to ODİS are therefore not uploaded to a server. Merging and PDF generation take place locally in the user’s browser and on the user’s device; the finished PDF is downloaded directly to the computer.

Use ODİS for free

Open the tool in your browser or install it as an app on supported devices.

Bug reports and improvement ideas: salihkimki@gmail.com

Sources


Comments

Leave a Reply